Quantcast
Channel: Comments on: This is Spinal Tap (no 30)
Browsing latest articles
Browse All 11 View Live

By: Sam Juliano

Of course I believe Mel Brooks’s THE PRODUCERS to be the best satire of the past 40 years, with BEING THERE as a close seond.

View Article



By: wondersinthedark

Yes, Sam, but as I said on the phone, THIS ISN’T ROCK…it’s like calling Babes in Arms pop music. You need to get the transparent pretentious phoneyness of the whole scene, to have heard the often...

View Article

By: John Greco

Well, since I have been reading a bio on Hal Ashby I will just add a few thoughts of my own. “Being There” is an excellent satire, based on a great book by Jerzy Kosinski. Along with The Last Detail...

View Article

By: Sam Juliano

John: Oddly enough, a number of people would pose SHAMPOO as Ashby’s greatest film, while others would defiantly go with the cultish HAROLD AND MAUDE, but I have alwats felt BEING THERE was the...

View Article

By: Bob Clark

Well, “Shampoo” is another one of those films that’s there but for the grace of its screenwriters. All due respect to Mr. Asby, but it’s easy to imagine that film directed by either Robert Towne, or...

View Article


By: Sam Juliano

You know Bob, in a sense it isn’t fair to Ashby that nearly all his films are to be credited to his screen writers. While that element is irrefutable, one must look at the way he orchestrates the...

View Article

By: Bob Clark

True, but I’m admirer of Towne’s & Beatty’s work, so it’s a longstanding thing that doesn’t quite have to do with Ashby himself on this one. I’m also pointing them out because of both of them tried...

View Article

By: John Greco

Bob is correct in crediting Shampoo to Beatty and Towne. According the bio, Beatty and Towne were controlling much of what happened, for example, the music to the soundtrack. Ashby wanted to used music...

View Article


By: Sam Juliano

Fair enough John. That info is pretty definitive as far as I see it. I’d be most interested when you get through the work to learn of Ashby’s ultimate complicity on some of the other films, including...

View Article


By: Robert

NIN and Tool were “serious artists” but Priest and Dio, etc, were a joke? Can you be serious??? At least they created great music without the constant use of swear words like NIN and Tool and Korn and...

View Article
Browsing latest articles
Browse All 11 View Live




Latest Images